| Platinum | Oregano's |
| Gold | Babbo Italian Eatery |
| Silver | Vogue Bistro |
| Bronze | Osteria Mia |
| Top Pick | Ben's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Carrabba's Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Dominics Bistro Italiano |
| Top Pick | Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Lucky's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Red Devil Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |